
There is something about families that makes it hard to stick to our boundaries. It’s perfectly normal to be better at boundaries with some people in your life than others. You may have no problem not answering the phone when a telemarketer calls or asking a stranger to stop smoking when you and your kids are nearby. It may be a little harder to draw the line with your friend who continues to drop by unannounced or your co-worker who asks you questions that are just a little too personal for your taste. You may find it increasingly easy to advocate for your kids at school or to find time for yourself to get the self-care that you need most. But somehow, no matter how much practice you have with setting and maintaining boundaries, practicing them with your family is an entirely different ballgame.
Our families, just like our bodies, strive to preserve homeostasis. Homeostasis is our body’s ability to maintain its internal condition as external conditions change. One example of this is your body’s core temperature. Your body’s temperature usually stays within a 1-2 degree range; whenever your temperature starts to rise or fall too much you begin to shiver or sweat, depending upon whether you are becoming too hot or too cool. In other words, your body is constantly adapting to your external environment so that your internal environment can stay as stable and constant as possible. In the same way, our family relationships tend to shift and adapt as external circumstances change so that things tend to stay predictable and comfortable.
“Our family is, except in rare circumstances, the most important emotional system to which most of us ever belong; it shapes the course and outcome of our lives. Relationships and functioning (physical, social, emotional, and spiritual) are interdependent, and a change in one part of the system is followed by compensatory change in other parts of the system…When a person changes his or her predictable emotional input in a family, reactions also change, interrupting the previous flow of interactions in the family. Other family members are likely to be jarred out of their patterned responses, and to react by trying to get the disrupter back in to place again.”
Monica McGoldrick, Exploring the Genogram
Our families are wired to reject changes. Just as our bodies start to sweat to cool off and maintain its temperature, so will our families seem to unconsciously rally to protect family norms. These responses and changes are almost always unconscious, but they serve the very important function of maintaining relational predictability in your family. Uncle Ebb will always pick a fight and talk about politics, you cousin Alice will always choose to stay neutral in whatever family conflict is occurring and your brother can always be relied upon to break the tension by breaking out the board games or doing dad joke improv. If the roles in your family feel fixed and unchangeable, then your family is probably really great at maintaining homeostasis.
Homeostatis in a family is not a bad thing. In fact, it’s a great thing when it allows a healthy family to readjust after a period of crisis. However, it does make creating change within your family especially hard work. Whenever you work to change a boundary in your family, you are not only working against patterns of behavior that have been established, but possibly against generations of relationships and patters that reinforce that same behavior.
What’s the best way to make a change?
Practice
By this point, you can predict some interactions that are likely to occur whenever you are with your family. If you are looking to create some change or reinforce a boundary, practice the words, tone, and even the body language you want to use. When we are stressed or caught off guard, we tend to resort back to old patterns. By practicing how you want to respond differently beforehand, you are giving yourself a better chance in the moment.
Expect some Chaos
When you respond differently than normal, be prepared for something unexpected to happen. A relative who normally keeps quiet may start to voice opinions or your actions may seem to cause frustration or confusion. Try to have compassion for your family members and their response to you; your actions are forcing them to respond differently and it’s rarely comfortable to be forced into change. Patience and compassion can help diffuse conflict while also sticking to your boundaries.
Get Help
Sometimes you just need some outside help to create change in your family. Oftentimes we are too close and too involved in the dance our families are engaged in to see what needs to be done to change the dance. Talk to a therapist or trusted friend to help gain some new insights into what might be the next best step with your family.
Wishing you luck with your holiday boundaries,
Selena














